Branding The State of Maine: Mayor Brennan vs. Governor LePage

May 9, 2013 | Branding, Business

Like this? Share it.

Recently, I attended two events hosted by the Portland Regional Chamber of Commerce where I was able to hear my local politicians in person. About two weeks ago I went to a luncheon where the keynote speaker was Michael Brennan, Mayor of Portland, Maine. Then yesterday, I went to their breakfast-time “Eggs & Issues” event where Paul LePage, Governor of Maine was the featured speaker.

As prominent local elected officials, I read and hear a lot about each of the men in the news and media, but I had never seen either of these politicians talk live.

Portland and Maine: Struggling but reaching

I live, work and own my business in Portland, Maine.

I grew up in Massachusetts and I had lived most of my adult life in Chicago. But in late 2005 my husband and I chose to move to Portland, Maine. We are one of the many people who move to Maine, and to the Portland area, because of the quality of life.

Both Portland and Maine end up getting some prominent listings whenever there are best/worst lists in magazines or web sites. Portland has been called the Foodiest Small Town, and we’re even ranked number 5 for America’s best Cities for Hipsters. Maine is currently listed as the most peaceful state in our country. Forbes Magazine has called Portland America’s most livable city. Yet, Forbes has also ranked Maine the worst state in the country for business the third year in a row.

While we all love living in Vacationland, the economic realities of living here can be tough.

Two speakers. Two reactions.

Let me describe the two speakers I heard, and my reaction.

Both speakers gave an overview of what’s going on in their domain. Brennan spoke about Portland; LePage, the bigger state.

Mayor Brennan talked about the struggles of Portland: lack of good jobs, and the need for better educated children. He then presented his list of key items he was working on to improve these areas. The Mayor talked about several private/public partnerships that were growing and helping the city achieve its goals. As he talked about his vision and love for Portland I felt my pride and energy growing. I was so glad to have chosen to live in Portland. I love the city already and now even better things are on the horizon. As his talk concluded, I approached one of the leaders of the private/public groups he mentioned and asked how I could get involved.

Governor LePage also talked about the struggles of Maine and they focused on the same two key themes: ramping up business in Maine and improving the education system. But what a contrast. The more he spoke the more down I felt. He really convinced me that the problems in Maine were practically unsolvable. He did not demonstrate to me that he had the vision, leadership and enthusiasm to accomplish great things. He had a lot of excuses, and it was always someone else’s fault as to why things were just so bad in the state of Maine. I walked out pretty glum.

Leaders are the face of your brand

Mayors, councilors, governors and presidents can inspire citizens. Elected politicians also represent and promote a region to outsiders. They become the “face” of a city or state.

Mayor Brennan inspired me to take action and to become part of his vision. Governor LePage just made me depressed.

I Love Portland, MaineDoes your brand inspire others to take action? Does your web site, the way you talk, and the way you present you and your brand convey an optimistic and energetic approach? People want to be surrounded by other winners. They want to work with other successful people so they can gain success, too.

2 comments

  1. Arthur Fink | May 22, 2013 at 5:06 pm

    Brennan is passionate, positive, creative, gracious, and wants to collaborate. Through his years in the legislature, he’s learned that some compromise is necessary, but that you need to be clear about your values and where compromise is wrong.

    LePage, on the other hand, is cynical, argumentative, and a bully who just wants things his way. He’s quick to start fights, even when the other sides (or sides) want to seek common ground.

    Emily tried to bring this contrast back to our own brand or identity. As an independent consultant, I want people to believe that it would be fun to work with me, that our joint search for solutions will be energizing and exciting, that I’ll respect them even as I recognize that I may have some skills that they lack. Of course if it were only fun with no results the euphoria wouldn’t last very long. But business (and politics) is about relationships, and most people want relationships that feel nurturing, satisfying, and engaging.

    In listening to Brennan, it’s easy to see that he enjoys finding ways to make the city of Portland work better, that he’s anxious to find people who will move forward on initiatives that he supports but can’t really work on himself, that he’s proud of the city and of the people who make it so great. It’s wonderfully energizing just to be with him.

  2. Emily Brackett | May 22, 2013 at 5:11 pm

    Arthur, thanks for your comment. It’s true that someone who is vibrant and fun can be ineffective, too. But generally when you can energize others, we all benefit.

Join the Conversation

 

 

 


Answer using numbers, not text. Thanks. Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.